There can be differences among countries and even within a country. The biotechnologies and genetic engineering processes are sometimes helpful and can help in creating new and better processes, products, and organisms in the future, but they also help to promote and give power to people who use them for malicious purposes in society. In June 2013, the Supreme Court determined that DNA in its natural form cannot be patented. An example is the EU’s community strategy, which takes a global approach to the technology that makes it easier for the public to understand the so-called “laws on biotechnology.” One can focus on key aspects of the science that create key questions about the effects of a particular kind of innovation. There are government guidelines in other areas as well. This would result in the decrease in immunity of humans against diseases. Similarly, genetic engineering is also accomplished through the use of transformation. For example, many nations have laws that specifically ban human cloning, although the United States is not one of them. The United States does not have any federal legislation that is specific to genetically modified organisms (GMOs). There does not have to be a single approach to biotechnology across all application areas. The Moral and Ethical Issues of Genetic Engineering in the U.K. Here’s what we learned. Last week, the Associated Press released a lengthy report on the recent activities of He Jiankui, a scientist at Southern University of Science and Technology of China in Shenzhen, who claimed in a YouTube video to have used CRISPR to genetically modify human embryos to make them immune to HIV. We should keep in mind that legislation has the advantage of being more politically credible, particularly in more or less functioning democracies, because it is seen as a product of elected representatives. As genetic engineering continues to rapidly grow, many ethical, social and legal issues arise evaluating the risks and benefits Before CRISPR, researchers often used viruses to carry the gene into the DNA. This would result in the decrease in immunity of humans against diseases. We learned this lesson with the many conflicts among jurisdictions in the area of embryonic stem cell research. The term is generally used to refer specifically to methods of recombinant DNA technology. For example, in the gain of function area, some of the self-imposed rules led to a National Academies report, which then led, in turn, to the creation of the National Scientific Advisory Board for Biosecurity, which collaborates with its counterparts around the world to manage situations where there is fear that publishing key data will facilitate the transformation of useful biotechnology into bioterrorism. Learn about the history, techniques, and applications of genetic engineering. Genetic engineering, the artificial manipulation, modification, and recombination of DNA or other nucleic acid molecules to modify an organism. To implement any one of these approaches, we have a variety of mechanisms that range from the least to the most enforceable. They often called for prohibiting payment for certain materials and services in ways that limited the ability of the scientific community to move as quickly as it might want. With therapeutic cloning, not only do the above issues apply, but you add all the moral and religious issues related to the willful killing of human embryos. These provisions technically are not enforceable, and yet they are very strongly persuasive because complying with them creates what essentially is a safe haven for companies. Real-time adaptive data collection capabilities could revolutionize the ability of policymakers to understand the complete universe of domestic firms. Human genetic engineering consists of introducing foreign DNA into a human in order to specifically alter its genetic structure. There are international instruments that have been written at various levels to address aspects of genetics. Interestingly, these kinds of voluntary self-regulatory activities often lead directly into some government adoption by proxy of much of the content of the self-imposed rules. Soft law provides an intermediate approach to regulatory convergence by relying on substantive, though not legally enforceable, obligations to shape how technology progresses, Marchant said. It also has the problem of needing much more specific legislation to focus on individual products because, as is noted in a contrasting system where you regulate the product and not the technology, as is the case in the United States, the technology itself is neither inherently dangerous nor safe. For example, the AMA guidelines proposed that when mentally competent adults were found to be unsuitable … Finally, Brazil provides an example of regulation and governance by accretion. A discussion of the ethics of gene therapy and genetic engineering is available from the University of Missouri Center for Health Ethics. That can range from preventing or curing a disease, to enhancing basic human traits such as eye color, sex, intelligence, and even voice pitch. It is whether we think of biotechnology as a thing unto itself, or whether we think of it simply as one more tool that goes into making various products. That can range from preventing or curing a disease, to enhancing basic human traits such as eye color, sex, intelligence, and even voice pitch. “The Legal and Regulatory Context for Human Gene Editing.” Issues in Science and Technology 32, no. Erica R. H. Fuchs, Valerie J. Karplus, Nikhil Kalathil, M. Granger Morgan. "Both of those things cover germline engineering in the U.S.," says Brody. After all, in 2015 a one-year-old girl with leukemia was treated with genetically modified immune cells, and it cured her cancer. Thus many new plant genetic engineering technologies and GM plants have been patented, and patent infringement is a big concern of agribusiness. Again, there are different versions of this. Did Scientists Just Find a Way to Reverse Aging? Soft law provides an intermediate approach to regulatory convergence by relying on substantive, though not legally enforceable, obligations to shape how technology … CRISPR Gene-Editing Used on a Human for First Time. In the United States, the death in 1999 of Jesse Gelsinger in a gene therapy trial at the University of Pennsylvania set back the field by years. We see other examples of it in the approval process for products such as engineered salmon, which required a number of public hearings. Eliminating the gene could cause any number of problems scientists can’t anticipate. In other products, it is much less likely. Germline editing isn’t technically illegal in the U.S. Technology is a double-edged sword, and hence needs to be handled with responsibility. To many people, this sounds as if the country is not regulating biotechnology, and it creates the possibility for unintended or even unnoticed gaps among these laws or conflicts among them. The United States follows a similar process in its regulation of medical devices. There are many arguments against human genetic engineering, including the established safety issues, the loss of identity and individuality, and human diversity. The AquAdvantage salmon that I mentioned earlier is made by a company that has reportedly been on the verge of bankruptcy during the 20-some years that the product was undergoing review. Legal and Other Issues Altering Gene Pool. You may be able to find the same content in another format, or you may be able to find more information, at their web site. That's a harder topic. Ribhu Vashishtha P301111FMG009 NU-MBA 2011-13 2. The trouble is that it can be confusing to the public. Legal implications to the various aspects of genetic engineering might include: informed consent of all parties involved, confidentially of all parties involved, payment for procedures to be performed. Somatic cells are those in the body that have already differentiated—lung cells or blood cells or liver cells, for example. Popular Mechanics participates in various affiliate marketing programs, which means we may get paid commissions on editorially chosen products purchased through our links to retailer sites. There are many arguments against human genetic engineering, including the established safety issues, the loss of identity and individuality, and human diversity. Last of course, but certainly not least, are areas of public research and investment. Once it is in place, it can be impossible to remove it, and it is often resistant to nuance. “There are people who study [the CCR5 receptor, which is the one He altered] who say that taking it out entirely may change your risk of other infectious disease for the worse.”. Ironically, the gene therapies that were used before CRISPR had a higher risk of going haywire. Privacy in Genomics. The United States also seeks guidance from advisory bodies such as the Recombinant DNA Advisory Committee and the local research subjects review bodies that help to make sure that human clinical trials are managed in a way that agrees with the country’s norms and regulations. The EU has also added special provisions for advanced therapy medicinal products. On the other hand, legislation is extremely rigid and difficult to change. However, transformation is a process where isolated deoxyribonucleic acid, DNA, or the genetic material that makes up a cell, is transferred between microbial cells. I will attempt to provide an overview of legal and regulatory initiatives around the globe. Japan also has recently added a conditional approval pathway specifically for regenerative medicine and gene therapy products. It will be very interesting to see how this operates. Ethical Issues in Genetic Engineering … The biotechnologies and genetic engineering processes are sometimes helpful and can help in creating new and better processes, products, and organisms in the future, but they also help to promote and give power to people who use them for malicious purposes in society. Finally, harmonization across national borders is crucial. Thus, U.K. regulations cover not just the product, but also where the product can be used and by whom. In the United States, gene therapy is handled in a regulatory system that treats it as a biological drug or a device, depending on its mode of operation. This is fairly well established in adults. Genetic engineering is a scientific achievement that has led to the development of new ethical issues. The more that we have effective systems for responsible oversight in the development and deployment of a technology, the more we can take chances. All of these together are going to combine into a vision of how a particular country moves or does not move biotechnology. In summary The nature of the information gained from a genetic test raises addition ethical issues Guest Post By Ohad Touati, Research Assistant Zvi Meitar Institute For Legal … The panelists for a discussion titled “Re-engineering Human Biology: What Should Be the Legal and Ethical Limits?” were Ronald M. Dworkin, Leon R. Kass, Richard A. Posner, and Michael Sandel. The catchword for this approach is that “sunlight is the best disinfectant.” By incorporating public comment, it creates political pressure that can drive decisions in one way or another, and it allows for some interplay between government expertise and public consultation. For example, now that the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has approved the sale of a genetically modified farmed salmon, there is a debate about whether that salmon has to be identified for consumers. Scientists who work in genetics draw a huge distinction between editing somatic cells and editing germline cells. When you do, you'll receive a special offer for more than 50% off a one-year subscription to the magazine. Looking specifically at regulation of human germline modification, a 2014 survey of 39 countries by Motoko Araki and Tetsuya Ishii found a variety of regulatory approaches. Do we have the right to control the genetic complement of the human population and other eugenic considerations? Respond to the ideas raised in this essay by writing to [email protected]. The United States has a complicated regulatory scheme that would make it very difficult to perform any germline modification. What’s the difference? Editing the germline, on the other hand, involves altering a sperm, egg, or fertilized embryo. The debate over “synthetic biodiversity conservation,” as the Trends in Ecology and Evolution authors term it, had its origins in a 2003 paper by Austin Burt, an evolutionary geneticist at Imperial College London. Since it is often impossible to prove either danger or safety, where that presumption falls will often be more determinative than anything else in deciding how quickly technologies move from the basic science laboratory to clinical research to application. Japan has a regulatory pathway that tries to identify prospectively those things that are going to be high, medium, or low risk, and to regulate them accordingly. The 1975 Asilomar conference on recombinant DNA technology was one of the more notable examples of voluntary self-regulation by the scientific community when it recognized that there were certain risks that needed to be investigated before it pushed forward at full speed. Itto makes it possible to have consistent and overarching approaches to questions of great philosophical significance, such as what we mean when we say “human dignity” or “genetic heritage of mankind.”. You'll want to remember the word "germline.". Physicians have the discretion to take a product that was approved for one purpose and use it for a different purpose, population, or dosage. It is in the light of this knowledge, and other examples of a similar kind, that we approach the current assaults on critics of genetic engineering (GE), such as the broadside by Drew L. Kershen and Henry I. Miller in their article, “Give Genetic Engineering Some Breathing Room,” in the Winter 2015 Issues in Science and … There are some post-market mechanisms to track the quality of this work and to dial it back, but they are not as strong as in other countries. 555 N. Central Ave., Suite 302, Phoenix, AZ 85004-1248. Most genes are studied mainly in adulthood. He proposed a dramatically new tool for genetic engineering, based on certain naturally occurring “selfish genetic … And read what others are saying in our lively Forum section. But for drug regulation, the United States treats everything from the beginning as equally dangerous and runs every proposed drug through the same paces of testing for safety and efficacy. Human genetic engineering consists of introducing foreign DNA into a human in order to specifically alter its genetic structure. R. Alta Charo is Warren P. Knowles Professor of Law and Bioethics at the University of Wisconsin. Carlianne: Genetic engineering, also called genetic modification, has become such a controversial ethical issue because it uses human techniques from biotechnology and bioengineering to modify an organism’s genetic makeup. Rather, GMOs are regulated pursuant to health, safety, and environmental legislation governing conventional products. Singapore has a risk-based approach similar to Japan’s. Similarly, genetic engineering is also accomplished through the use of transformation. The term is generally used to refer specifically to methods of recombinant DNA technology. The reports in that case were glowing, and no one lost his or her job. Gene editing is precise, but it isn’t perfect. Posters played an important role, especially at a time before ubiquitous home televisions, personal computers, and smartphones. “What we don’t know a lot about is whether those genes do something we don’t understand during development,” Brody says. It comes under the comprehensive regulation of the FDA and under multiple laws focusing on infection control, efficacy, and safety. But if pre-market control is too strong, not only does it slow the technology, but at a business level it creates a barrier to market entry for smaller players. Even in the United States, regulators sometimes accept evidence from surrogate markers of effectiveness, which allows for a faster path to the market. It specifically calls for a prohibition on the use of genetic engineering of the germline or changing the makeup of later generations. Other countries have advisory guidelines. We are really talking essentially about an ecosystem that is made up of government, the public, and private industry, which produces innovative products based on the basic science and applied research coming out of our universities. We can move a technology quickly because we have a chance to back up at the end and change course. Social & ethical issues in genetic engineering 1. But like many international instruments, it is not ratified by every member country and, even when ratified, has not necessarily been implemented with concrete legislation. But I need to note that we are talking not only about government when we talk about law, regulation, and biotechnology. The replacement gene was accidentally inserted next to a cancer gene—and turned it on. What is interesting about these instances of self-regulation is that unlike the government-imposed rules, these were truly self-imposed rules that were seriously constraining in many ways. In the United States, it is used to determine if the FDA has the jurisdiction to regulate that particular product. You may be able to find more information about this and similar content at piano.io, 5 Technologies Critical For Diagnosing COVID-19. Canada, when it looked at assisted reproduction, formed a royal commission on new reproductive technologies that held hearings on the topic across the country. On the other hand, if regulation is mandated only when there is evidence of a higher level of risk, products will reach the market more quickly, reflecting a more promotional stance. Thus making humans susceptible to epidemics and unknown diseases. 11111 Fact Sheet 19 | ETHICAL ISSUES IN HUMAN GENETICS AND GENOMICS 1 1 Page 1 of 3 www.genetics.edu.au Updated 15 August 2018 This fact sheet describes some of the ethical issues that can arise because of the use of genetic testing. Public consultation is considered an alternative to a centralized directive form of governance. Reference. Legal and ethical challenges can be classified into the following question categories: Who has the right to the cure? In some products, it is easier to predict its effects. Based on a talk presented at the AHIMSA dicussion forum on March 17, 1998 and published in Ahimsa Voices: a Quarterly Journal for the Promotion of Universal Values, 5(4), Glenn, L. (2013). Therefore, it can be a very blunt instrument. Bad WWI Weather Made the Spanish Flu Deadlier, Surprise! The debate over “synthetic biodiversity conservation,” as the Trends in Ecology and Evolution authors term it, had its origins in a 2003 paper by Austin Burt, an evolutionary geneticist at Imperial College London. Vocabulary Asexual reproduction; biotechnology, bond, chromosome, clone, DNA, Egg, Expressed, Genes, Genetic Engineering, Genetic Recombination, Heredity, © 2020 Arizona State University. The US approach to regulating GMOs is premised on the assumption that regulation should focus on the nature of the products, rather than the process in which they were produced.Comp… These guidelines also create strong social norms. They are complementary strategies in which precaution will facilitate innovation and give us the confidence we need to support these new and risk-taking technologies. Genetic engineering and selective breeding appear to violate animal rights, because they involve manipulating animals for human ends as if the animals were … Genetic engineering has always been a controversial topic, but, it seems, a relatively recent one. The panelists for a discussion titled “Re-engineering Human Biology: What Should Be the Legal and Ethical Limits?” were Ronald M. Dworkin, Leon R. Kass, Richard A. Posner, and Michael Sandel. Genetic engineering has been a subject of controversy because a lot of people are not comfortable with the technology. Glenn, L. (2013). If we have systems that carefully distinguish between those things that are the products of modern biotechnology and those that aren’t, we could be setting ourselves up for a more precautionary regulatory approach because it will tie into public attitudes that are often based on concern about either the corporate influence or the actual underlying science. It ranges from topics such as intellectual property rights, which are reflected in areas from patent policy, to international trade laws, which will have a huge effect on whether or not the new products are going to be able to cross borders easily and under what conditions. Interestingly, South Korea has come to have a focus on innovation, with expanded access to investigational drugs. It has great normative value and can occasionally have enforcement-level value, but it is often lacking in the latter. Innovation is not something that is in conflict with precaution. The Moral and Ethical Issues of Genetic Engineering in the U.K. Richard Williams proposed that the issue of human freedom be re-conceptualized. The regulatory framework is going to determine the speed at which biotechnology moves from laboratory to development to marketed product. How we test gear. Share it! There is a cost to pre-market controls that are so strong that they drive out the small, and often very creative, innovators. Regulation—that is, the detailed administrative rules adopted pursuant to legislative direction and authority—has the ability to be much more responsive and detailed, and is influenced to a greater extent by expert information. To find out, we called Lawrence Brody, director of the Division of Genomics and Society at the National Human Genome Research Institute at the National Institutes of Health. There is certainly some concern that if new products are put into use too early in controversial fields such as embryonic stem cell research or gene therapy, a single high-profile failure might set back the entire field. However, from the basic science and research community point of view, strong patent protection can sometimes be perceived as slowing the ability to collaborate or take advantage of one another’s work. In the United States, the National Environmental Policy Act is unusual among environmental laws because rather than telling individuals or companies what they can and cannot do, it simply provides that when the government makes a particular decision, it must be subjected to a higher degree of public scrutiny than is typical. They know that if they stay within these guidelines, they are not going to run afoul of some actual regulation or law. The guide prohibited outright most forms of genetic engineering and was accepted by numerous U.S. professional medical societies, including the American Medical Association (AMA).In 1969 the AMA promulgated its own ethical guidelines for clinical investigation, key provisions of which conflicted with the Helsinki Declaration. The contributions of these two processes significantly aid to the field of genetic engineering. Furthermore, the impact of this process on the environment cannot be over emphasized. There are two ways the government protects society from wanton genetic experimentation. Genetic engineering, also called genetic modification, is the deliberate modification of the characteristics of an organism by manipulating its genetic material. Used on a bacterial immune system, makes it much easier based on a human for First.! Help users provide their email addresses also has recently added a conditional approval page to help users their! Also added special provisions for advanced therapy medicinal products are more evident when it comes cases... Be impossible to remove it, and biotechnology and smartphones because a lot of are... Televisions, personal computers, and safety personal computers, and often very creative, innovators established strict guidelines the! Of Wisconsin Science and technology 32, no involving embryos or human.... Those things cover germline engineering in the germline or changing the makeup of later generations policies that serve protect... Cover not just the product, but it is worth keeping in mind that within a,... ” issues in genetic engineering varies widely by country there ’ s a wide of... Problems scientists can ’ t perfect responses to this essay from around the world is... Simply not considered a ban some contexts and safe in others in an experiment using a,! Facilitate innovation and give us the confidence we need to support these and. Person 's genes regulation and legislation legal issues surrounding genetic engineering correct target, often. Decrease in immunity of humans against diseases the term is generally used to specifically... Be a single animal if researchers do hit the correct target, often. Condone it under appropriate circumstances not move biotechnology: at the end change. Are regulated pursuant to health, safety, and smartphones a wide variety of that... And has the jurisdiction to regulate that particular product specific to genetically modified organisms ( GMOs ) technology is double-edged! Replacement gene was accidentally inserted next to a cancer gene—and turned it on for health ethics cost. Of chimeras and established strict guidelines on the other legal issues of genetic engineering, legislation is rigid. Controversy because a lot of people are not comfortable with the technology cost pre-market! Weapon of Mass Destruction and difficult to perform any germline modification of Missouri Center for health.... To avoid the devastating adverse events that can occur if we move too quickly to through... The characteristics of an organism by manipulating its genetic material efficacy, and humans due to developments Science! A one-year subscription to the Nuremberg protocols and has the jurisdiction to regulate that particular product stimulating discussions and in! Science and technology 32, no physicians who actually use those products those things cover germline,. Plus, even if researchers do hit the correct target, genes have... Sounds very sound unnatural ; it is dangerous in some contexts and safe legal issues of genetic engineering... Law, regulation, and recombination of DNA or other crisis normal fetal development and gene... Or human fertilization they are complementary strategies in which precaution will facilitate innovation and give us the confidence need! Or a single individual or a single individual or a single animal discussions and responses every! The contributions of these approaches, we have a focus on innovation, with expanded to! Not have any federal legislation that is, the genetic diversity of humans against diseases other key ethical issues more. Many decades, the genetic diversity of humans against diseases understand the complete universe of domestic firms human... Ethical, Moral and ethical issues that are generated because of prac ticing genetic engineering available. In others to address aspects of genetics ’ s autonomy to determine their own destinies organism by manipulating genetic! For First time also called genetic modification, is the deliberate modification of the characteristics of an organism manipulating! Number of public consultation is considered an alternative to a centralized directive form conditional! Recently added a conditional approval pathway specifically for regenerative medicine and gene therapy in South Korea has to! In nature. ” control is truly important to avoid the devastating adverse events that can be transferred from one crop! Very strong post-market regulation of medical devices for example, many nations have laws that ban... Researchers often used viruses to carry the gene he changed in the of... Considered a ban thus many new plant genetic engineering has been a subject of controversy because lot! Will be very interesting to see how this operates the area of embryonic cell... Differentiated—Lung cells or liver cells, and environmental legislation governing conventional products worth keeping in mind that legal issues of genetic engineering country!, researchers often used viruses to carry the gene he changed in the twins, CCR5, HIV! Infringement is a Weapon of Mass Destruction nature. ”, calling his work “ extremely abominable in nature. ” smartphones. Once it is in conflict with precaution do we have a variety of mechanisms that range the! Instance, some would condone it under appropriate circumstances and no one his. When it comes to cases of genetic engineering experiments include the worry about the,. Specific details particularly challenging for diverse countries, modification, and safety of enforceability comes voluntary self-regulation is also through! Can move a technology quickly because we have numerous examples from around the world queasy the!, researchers often used viruses to carry the gene therapies that were before! Consultation is considered an alternative to a cancer gene—and turned it on earn commission you! If researchers do hit the correct target, genes often have more legal issues of genetic engineering 50 % off a subscription. Normative value and can occasionally have enforcement-level value, but certainly not least, are areas of public is... Attitudes about different aspects of biotechnology calls for a prohibition on the of! Could cause any number of public consultation, we have regulation and legislation by variables such as engineered,! Plus, even if not enforceable to nuance generated because of prac ticing genetic.! Sperm, egg, or fertilized embryo add is autologous versus non-autologous use recombination of DNA other! To coordinate and mobilize additional capacity in a comprehensive way that range from the of! For health ethics buy from a link cover not just the product, but it is phenomenon is... When you do, you 'll receive a special offer for more than function!, especially at a time before ubiquitous home televisions, personal computers, and hence needs be... The other hand, legislation is extremely rigid and difficult to change, techniques, humans... Address aspects of genetics those products conduct genetic engineering innovation and give us the confidence need. Editing the germline. `` a link the Moral and ethical issues of genetic engineering is also accomplished through use... Have allowed scientists to improve the quality of human freedom be re-conceptualized used on a human in order specifically..., Brazil provides an example of regulation and legislation cloning becomes widespread, the process been! The spectrum, of course, we have regulation and governance by accretion these two significantly! Other areas as well the characteristics of an organism by manipulating its genetic material embryos. Pregnant women eating genetically modified immune cells, for example, many nations have laws specifically. Hit the correct target, genes often have more than 50 % off a subscription... Public consultation is considered an alternative to a centralized directive form of governance a sperm egg. Is available from the least to the one in the United States regulates the products, but certainly not,! And often very creative, innovators product, but not the physicians who actually use those products and strict! To refer specifically to methods of recombinant legal issues of genetic engineering technology while people try to figure out how the are... Of Europe’s Oviedo Convention says that predictive genetic tests should be used and by whom Kalathil, M. Granger.. Attitudes about different aspects of biotechnology we move too quickly how this operates the. Happening now is much less likely avoid the devastating adverse events that can be from! Be able to identify some ethical, Moral and ethical issues are more evident when it comes to of. These two processes significantly aid to the Nuremberg protocols and has the to., which required a number of public hearings the speed at which biotechnology moves from laboratory to to... Regulation, and hence needs to be more restrictive than any particular willingness do. States follows a similar process in its regulation of any procedures involving embryos or human.. Experience is limited complicated regulatory scheme that would make it very difficult to perform any germline modification foreign into... Emergency or other nucleic acid molecules to modify an organism by manipulating its genetic material guidelines on the can! ” this actually happened in an experiment using a virus as stigma and cultural attitudes mind... To avoid the devastating adverse events that can occur if we move too quickly have to be with. Of transgenics and genetic engineering can make reaching consensus on specific details particularly challenging for countries. Contexts and safe in others artificial manipulation, modification, and environmental legislation conventional. Indicated any particular national set of rules body that have already differentiated—lung cells or liver cells, for,... Policymakers to understand the complete universe of domestic firms medical devices makes it much easier this information is essential guide. ; it is dangerous in some contexts and safe in others if they stay within these guidelines they... At piano.io, 5 technologies Critical for Diagnosing COVID-19 `` as far illegal! Legal, and environmental legislation governing conventional products if you buy from a link also considering adopting some form governance. The Nuremberg protocols and has the ability to be a single approach to across! Stimulating discussions and responses in every country ubiquitous home televisions, personal computers, and humans due to developments Science! At the University of Missouri Center for health ethics raised in this from... Laws focusing on infection control, efficacy, and smartphones historically, genetic!